AI visibility tools compared: Otterly, Peec AI, ZipTie and manual work
Four AI visibility tools side by side on covered platforms and application, plus the manual route that proves the same thing without a subscription.
Lees dit in het Nederlands →$ compare --tools=4 --manual=1
AI visibility tools compared: Otterly, Peec AI, ZipTie and manual work
Four tools measure whether your business appears in AI answers: Otterly AI, Peec AI, ZipTie and LLMrefs. They differ mainly in which platforms they cover and what they focus on, and for a first measurement a spreadsheet with a fixed question list is enough. This piece puts all the options side by side. We don't sell any of these tools and haven't tested them ourselves over a long period; the comparison rests on the coverage the makers publish themselves.
Anyone who wants to know whether their business is mentioned in ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google's AI Overviews needs a measurement instrument. The choice is between four specialised tools and a spreadsheet with discipline. Which of the five fits depends on how many questions you track, how many brands you measure and which platforms matter for your clients.
01 / the instrumentWhy you choose a measurement instrument first
Without a fixed measurement, any statement about AI visibility is an opinion. Answers differ per session and per phrasing, so only a fixed question list that you repeat at fixed intervals produces an outcome that still tells you something next month. How that benchmark works is set out in how you measure AI visibility; this piece is about the tools you use to run that measurement.
To be clear: this is a young corner of the field. In the Netherlands, this category is still searched for relatively little (according to NL search data from DataForSEO, August 2026, about 40 to 70 searches per month for terms like ai visibility tool and ai seo tools), and the tools themselves are young. So expect coverage and capabilities to shift, and check with the maker what applies today.
02 / the comparisonFour tools and the spreadsheet side by side
The differences aren't in what the tools promise, but in which platforms they read and what their reporting focuses on. This is the coverage as the makers publish it (as of August 2026):
| Option | Covers | Focuses on | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Otterly AI | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews | Your share in AI answers next to that of competitors (share of AI voice) | Anyone who wants to see the competitive comparison across the three major platforms |
| Peec AI | ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Copilot | Monitoring across many platforms at once, at scale | Anyone who wants broad coverage, including Claude and Copilot, or tracks multiple brands |
| ZipTie | Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity | Brand mentions and the sentiment around them | Anyone who mainly wants to know how the brand is spoken about |
| LLMrefs | Linking SEO keywords to AI visibility | Seeing what your existing keywords do in AI answers | Anyone who already has an SEO keyword list and wants to extend it |
| Manual work (spreadsheet) | Any platform you open yourself | Fixed question list, one measurement point per month, ticks per platform | A first stage, one brand, a manageable number of questions |
We deliberately leave out prices: they change quickly in this segment and weren't in our source. And again the honesty that a comparison calls for: we haven't tested any of the four in production over a long period. What's here is the published coverage, not a practical verdict.
03 / the zero optionWhy manual work is a valid choice
The spreadsheet isn't a poverty version of a tool, but the same measurement without a subscription. You fix your question list, open each platform, note per question whether you appear, and repeat that every month at the same time. How you set up such a first round in half an hour is set out in how you check whether your business appears in ChatGPT.
A tool speeds up your measurement; the benchmark is what makes it reliable.
What manual work doesn't give you is scale and history without effort. Twenty-five questions across four platforms is half a day per month; two hundred questions across five platforms for three brands is no longer manual work. That's where the tools' territory begins.
04 / the choiceWhere you start, and when you switch
Our advice is simple: start with manual work and a fixed benchmark, and only switch to a tool once the number of questions, platforms or brands makes the manual work unsustainable. That way you first learn what a meaningful question and a meaningful outcome are, and afterwards you buy with purpose rather than on the promise of a dashboard.
If you do choose a tool straight away, choose based on the platforms where your clients search, not the longest feature list. A B2B audience that works a lot with Claude and Copilot gets little from ChatGPT-only coverage; anyone who mainly needs to be found on Google looks first at AI Overviews coverage.
When choosing, pay attention to two practical points, whatever brand is on the box. First: can you export your measurement series, so your history moves with you if you later switch or return to the spreadsheet. Second: can you enter your own question list instead of a generated one, because the measurement is only comparable to your baseline measurement if the questions stay the same.
And for anyone who'd rather not run the measurement themselves at all: that's also available as a service, including a report and improvement points. What such an outsourced baseline measurement involves is set out on the scan page. For anyone whose clients don't come in through online search or AI answers, the reverse applies: none of these five options is worth your time, and that's the most useful outcome of this piece.
What does an AI visibility tool do?+
Which AI visibility tool is best?+
Can I measure AI visibility without a tool?+
Which platforms should the measurement cover at minimum?+
How often should you measure AI visibility?+
Would you rather know where you stand straight away, without comparing tools yourself?
The scan
This is the baseline measurement: fixed search questions on ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Google. Current amounts are on the pricing page. Even without a follow-up, you keep the report.
This text was produced with AI assistance and checked and approved by a human before publication.